Don’t Ignore a Notice of Contest of Lien

David Adelstein | Florida Construction Legal Updates

A recent case, Jon M. Hall Company, LLC v. Canoe Creek Investments, LLC, 49 Fla.L.Weekly D812a (Fla. 2d DCA 2024), demonstrates four important things when it comes to liens:

  1. An owner can shorten the time period to foreclose on the lien, whether against the real property or a lien transfer bond, to 60 days by recording a notice of contest of lien;
  2. An owner can transfer a lien to a lien transfer bond during litigation;
  3. An owner can record a notice of contest of lien to force the lienor to amend its lawsuit to sue the lien transfer bond surety within 60 days; and
  4. A contractors’ failure to amend its lawsuit to sue the lien transfer bond within 60 days will extinguish its rights to pursue a claim against the lien transfer bond, and will otherwise extinguish the lien, fairly or unfairly.

Here are the key facts in Jon M. Hall Company:

  • 4/14/22 – Contractor recorded claim of lien for $825,639.46
  • 5/17/22 – Owner transferred Contractor’s claim of lien to a lien transfer bond
  • 5/20/22 – Owner recorded a notice of contest of Contractor’s claim of lien
  • Late May 2022 – Contractor recorded amended claim of lien for $1,837,516.76
  • 6/14/22 – Contractor filed lawsuit against Owner including a lien foreclosure as to its amended claim of lien. Contractor did not sure the lien transfer bond surety
  • 7/1/22 – Owner transferred Contractor’s amended claim of lien to a lien transfer bond
  • 7/1/22 – Owner recorded a notice of contest of Contractor’s amended claim of lien
  • Contractor did not amend its lien foreclosure lawsuit to sue the lien transfer bond within 60 days
  • 12/19/22 – Owner moved for partial summary judgment on Contractor’s lien foreclosure lawsuit. “[Owner] asserted that transferring to bond and recorded notices of contest as to both [Contractor’s] Original Claim of Lien and Amended Claim of Lien had shortened the time for [Contractor] to bring action against the bond. [Contractor] had failed to timely do so, thereby resulting in automatic extinguishment of the lien as a matter of law.”
  • Trial court granted Owner’s motion for partial summary judgment holding that “[Owner’s] transfer and recording of the notice of context as to the Amended Claim of Lien during the litigation shortened the time for [Contractor] to bring a claim against the bond to sixty days, and [Contractor’s] failure to timely do so extinguished its lien automatically as a matter of law.”

The Contractor moved for a petition for a writ of certiorari to quash the trial court’s order that held its lien was extinguished as a matter of law.

A lienor has one year under Florida Statute Section 713.22 to foreclose on a claim of lien. This time period may be shortened to 60 days by an owner recording a notice of context of lien under Florida Statute Section 713.24.  The notice of contest statute provides, “[t]he lien of any lienor upon whom such notice is served and who fails to institute a suit to enforce his or her lien within 60 days after service of such notice shall be extinguished automatically.”

Separately, under Florida Statute 713.24, a lien against real property can be transferred to the security of a lien transfer bond which removes the collateral of the lien from the real property to the lien transfer bond.

Construing Florida Statutes 713.22 and 713.24 together, “under the plain statutory language, where a lien is transferred to a bond during litigation, and the owner records a notice of contest, the lienor has “60 days” “within which to commence an action to enforce any claim of lien or claim against a bond,” or else the “lien . . . shall be extinguished automatically.” Jon M. Hall Company, supra (internal citations omitted).

Here, it is true that [Contractor’s] Original Claim of Lien was recorded, transferred, and noticed for contest before the litigation commenced. However, before the June 2022 lawsuit, [Contractor] also recorded an Amended Claim of Lien, more than doubling the amount claimed. [Contractor] thereafter filed its complaint, expressly acknowledging and seeking to recover on the higher Amended Claim of Lien. Two weeks later, [Owner] transferred the Amended Claim of Lien to the bond and recorded its notice of contest thereof, just as it had with the original one.

Thus, after [Contractor] commenced litigation on its Amended Claim of Lien, [Owner’s] actions in transferring the Amended Claim of Lien to bond under section 713.24 and then recording its notice of contest of the Amended Claim of Lien under section 713.22(2) operated to shorten the time period for [Contractor] to bring an action against the surety on the bond to sixty days. 

***

On that question, the statutory language is quite clear: after [Contractor] “commenced” this “proceeding to enforce a lien” expressly seeking to recover on its Amended Claim of Lien, “during such proceeding, the lien [wa]s transferred” by Owner.  When [Owner], as the owner of the property, recorded its notice of contest of the transferred Amended Claim of Lien, that “shorten[ed] the time . . . within which to commence an action to enforce any claim of lien or claim against a bond or other security.”  Contractors failure to seek to claim against the bond within sixty days thereafter caused its lien to “be extinguished automatically” by operation of law. 

***

[Contractor] also asserts that both of [Owner’s] notices of contest of lien were invalid because they were recorded after [Owner] had already transferred the claims of lien to bond. But [Contractor] has not cited, nor have we found, any support for this claim. Indeed, the only case Hall cites for this proposition involved the same order of events, without suggesting there was anything improper about it. 

Jon M. Hall Company, supra (internal citations omitted).

Look, when it comes to claims of lien, do yourself a favor.  Use a construction lawyer.  Use a lawyer that understands liens, and importantly, Florida’s Lien Law.  I cannot emphasize these points enough.  If you don’t, you can get caught with gotcha tactics or crazy nuances under Florida’s Lien Law.  I don’t necessary agree with the holding in this case.  Regardless, when receiving a notice of contest of lien, you need to respect the implications and make sure rights are immediately preserved.  Otherwise, you get caught in the scenario here where a lienor had a $1.8 Million lien extinguished. OUCH!!!


When one of your cases is in need of a construction expert, estimates, insurance appraisal or umpire services in defect or insurance disputes – please call Advise & Consult, Inc. at 888.684.8305, or email experts@adviseandconsult.net.

Leave a Reply

%d bloggers like this: