Challenging Total Denials Under “Weeks, Months, or Years” Seepage Exclusions: The First-Thirteen-Days Argument

Advise & Consult, Inc.

When a concealed water loss goes undetected for several weeks, insurers routinely issue a complete coverage denial under the standard exclusion for constant or repeated seepage or leakage occurring over a period of “weeks, months, or years.” A recurring coverage question for public adjusters and policyholders is whether that exclusion bars the entire loss—or whether coverage remains available for damage sustained during the initial thirteen days before the “weeks” threshold is met.

A review of federal and state case law shows that while the “first thirteen days” theory has gained traction in several jurisdictions, courts remain sharply divided, and success hinges heavily on forensic proof.

Authority Supporting Coverage for Initial Damage

At least three courts have recognized that an seepage exclusion tied to a multi-week timeframe does not automatically eliminate coverage for damage occurring before that threshold is reached:

  • Wheeler v. Allstate Insurance Company: After a plumbing failure flooded a seasonal cabin for roughly two months, the Tenth Circuit held that the insured could pursue recovery for damage sustained within the first thirteen days, provided that early damage could be separated from subsequent deterioration. Expert testimony establishing that building materials were already beyond repair within the first week was sufficient to defeat summary judgment.
  • Hicks v. American Integrity Insurance Company of Florida: Interpreting an exclusion that specifically applied to leakage lasting “14 days or more,” a Florida appellate court held that the policy did not unambiguously exclude damage occurring during the first thirteen days, directing partial summary judgment for the policyholder on that issue.
  • Danganan v. American Family Mutual Insurance Company: A federal district court in Nevada found coverage for water damage caused by a rodent-damaged plumbing line despite weeks of ongoing leakage. Reading the seepage exclusion alongside a policy provision preserving coverage for water escaping after rodent damage, the court identified an ambiguity and granted summary judgment on breach of contract to the insureds.

Authority Rejecting the Thirteen-Day Theory

Conversely, a growing body of decisions holds that the temporal language in a seepage exclusion defines the excluded peril (the duration of the leak itself) rather than carving out a grace period for early damage:

  • Feldman v. Citizens Property Insurance Corp.: Florida’s Fourth District Court of Appeal declined to recognize an automatic thirteen-day coverage window under a “weeks, months or years” exclusion, distinguishing Hicks on the ground that Hicks involved an explicit fourteen-day policy threshold.
  • McKain v. Safeco Insurance Company of America: A federal court in Montana held that the duration requirement describes the excluded peril rather than the timing of the damage. Because the leak persisted for approximately thirty days, the entire resulting loss—including damage from the initial days—was excluded.
  • Karon v. Safeco Insurance Company of America: Rejecting early-damage coverage after a refrigerator line discharged roughly 1,000 gallons per day, an Arizona federal court reasoned that the exclusion applies to leakage occurring over weeks, not merely damage manifesting after weeks, particularly when read alongside concurrent or sequential causation language.
  • Croxdale v. Travelers Home & Marine Insurance Company: Expressly rejecting Wheeler and Hicks, an Iowa federal court concluded that the durational clause modifies the leakage itself rather than the resulting loss.

The Evidentiary Hurdle: Segregation of Damages

Even in jurisdictions receptive to the first-thirteen-days argument, the theory carries a demanding evidentiary burden. Once a multi-week leak is discovered, distinguishing immediate water damage from subsequent rot, mold, or structural deterioration is technically challenging. A standard repair scope detailing total restoration costs does not establish when specific components failed.

This evidentiary gap proved fatal in Landrum v. Allstate Insurance Company, where the Eleventh Circuit affirmed summary judgment for the insurer following a twenty-five-day leak because the policyholder offered no evidence segregating early damage from later deterioration. By contrast, the policyholder in Wheeler survived summary judgment specifically because expert evidence demonstrated that certain materials were rendered unsalvageable within the first seven days.

Practical Takeaways for Claims Professionals

When evaluating a total denial based on a constant or repeated seepage exclusion:

  1. Check Jurisdiction and Policy Wording: Determine whether controlling precedent treats the temporal threshold as modifying the loss or the leakage, and verify whether the policy uses broad “weeks, months or years” phrasing or an explicit day count (e.g., 14 days).
  2. Assess Forensic Segregation Early: Before advancing a partial-coverage demand, consult with restoration experts, engineers, or building consultants to determine whether physical evidence—such as flow rates, material saturation thresholds, or failure timelines—can credibly establish that specific building components were ruined within the initial thirteen days.

Without reliable expert proof separating initial loss from long-term deterioration, arguing the legal ambiguity of the exclusion is unlikely to overcome summary judgment.


When one of your cases is in need of a construction expert, estimates, insurance appraisal or umpire services in defect or insurance disputes – please call Advise & Consult, Inc. at 801.641.8304, or email experts@adviseandconsult.net.

Leave a Reply